Max Gladstone's _Empress of Forever_

[liralen]

Empress of Forever by Max Gladstone

My rating: 5 of 5 stars


Max Gladstone did what I've been dreaming of doing and he did it really really well.

He took the Journey to the West and translated it into pure space opera and did it writing only one chapter for every 20 in the old books, and he did it with style and beautiful writing. He pulled it all together with his own plot that made sense, with really incredible characters (and in his usual way, most of them are women) and an overarching beautifully paced escalation of action that charges up the reader's ability to learn and comprehend what's going on as quickly as Vivian Lao learns about the universe she lands in and how it works (even when some of the whys are beautifully made inconsequential) and finally has to deal with how it makes her work and feel.

He gives a solid framework for the timescales involved, the legends that are born, and what felt oddly Chinese was the rooted grounding in family and what it really can mean. He even had solid footing in the realms of Buddhist practice. He's done his homework.

I'll admit that as a Chinese woman, it felt odd to have him take both my culture and my gender and *write it*. And I'm sure there are going to be people yelling about cultural appropriation, but... damn, what he's done here is what writers are *for*. Examining and understanding and then creating from what isn't known to allow readers to have an even deeper understanding. I could as much yell about writers appropriating coding or science (and with writers who do it WRONG I do), which are also cultures in their own way, as about being Chinese or female (and homosexual, which amuses me to see my tendency to write homosexual men from the other side).

Given that the only thing that's actually Chinese is Vivian Lao's background, and the rest is actually all supposed to be about space aliens, he's allowed. *laughs*

Anyway, I loved it. I recommend it. I will probably wallow in its entirety a few more times just to inspire myself. And especially rejoice in a telling of why Tyrannical Empires should be fought against no matter how terrible and huge they seem and how small and weak and helpless we might think we are in the face of them. Dragons can be beaten.



View all my reviews

Comments

[incandescens]

I absolutely loved this too.

[liralen]

Yay!! I thought you might.

[incandescens]

It is a beautiful, marvellous book.

(There was an actual moment when I realised who he was correlating to who from the Journey to the West, and I went, "Of course!")

[liralen]

YES!! I loved that sudden snap of understanding who was whom... xD

[archangelbeth]

I clearly need to get enough brains to read this!

[liralen]

Yes!! It is so fun, and on the most part he does a good job of either explaining or the good kind of handwaving...the coding handwaving I actually appreciated a good deal because he was correct in concept without heading into bad amounts of detail.

He really kept the focus on the people.

[rraven]

Thanks for this review. I'd been wondering about the cultural/gender appropriation aspects but I'd heard so many good things about this author that I recently picked up the book and plan to read it on our upcoming trip. To, well, Yellowstone and points north. It sounds like I'll have a great story to complement the travel adventures.

You'd mentioned T Kingfisher in your last post. I discovered her fairy tale retellings a few months ago and have been working through them. I'm not sure how we ended up reading/doing so many similar things given how infrequently we see each other.

One of the fun things with reading T Kingfisher's books is that she lives in the town just south of where we were when we lived in NC. I see some of that ending up in her writing.

[liralen]

*laughs* So many points of co-incidence... Hope you have a blast with the book and the trip!

There are points where it does feel a bit like a man writing what he thinks a woman would think or feel, but it really just helped me remember that the width of possibilities within a gender are vast. Some might argue that no woman would be as focussed as Vivian, but I know my own past... and remember those days when nothing mattered but the work.

And I did my best to pass as mostly a man at work anyway.

[erikred]

I finished this last week-- what a joy, and what a ride! I'll admit, I didn't catch the Journey to the West connections until I'd nearly finished it, but that didn't diminish it at all.

[liralen]

Yay! It was so much fun. I'm glad that didn't diminish it at all!!

I think, for me, at least, it was the controlling crown that made me go, "Wait a minute... I KNOW this..." But... the plot is so utterly a Max Gladstone creation that I just loved it for itself. Utterly. xD